Withholding an Ex-Partner's Property Until Yours Is Returned
Start a free AI-assisted chat and connect with an experienced Idaho attorney, with no obligation.
Reviewed & verified by A. Jason Velez, Esq.*
Managing Attorney, 1LAW · Last reviewed January 1, 2026
Legal Inquiry
Consumer Legal Issue
I have her stuff, she has my stuff. I offered a trade and she refused. Can I get in trouble for not giving her things back?
Attorney Answer
No, you are not entitled to hold her belongings as leverage — and yes, you can get in trouble for it, even though she is in the wrong about your property.
Idaho, like every state, treats each person's property claim as its own separate matter. When someone demands the return of their own property and you refuse, you can be sued civilly for conversion — the wrongful exercise of control over another person's property — and, depending on how a prosecutor views your intent, a refusal to release property after a clear demand can also draw a criminal complaint. Her failure to return your truck clip and car roof does not create a legal right to keep her dishes and kitchen items. It creates a claim you file against her.
The practical risk is not just legal. Right now you have two clean facts on your side: she refused you access to your property in October 2024, and in March 2025 she said your property is gone. Those facts support a claim for the value of what she disposed of. Every month you keep her things, you hand her a counterclaim and you make yourself look like the party acting badly if a judge ever hears this.
What you can do
1. Photograph and itemize everything of hers in the unit, on one dated list, before you release anything. 2. Send her a written message — text or email, so it is timestamped — offering a specific date, time and place to collect her items, with no conditions attached. 3. Have her sign a receipt for the items when she takes them, or hand them over in front of a witness and photograph the exchange. If she refuses to sign, note the date and the witness's name. 4. Send her a separate written demand for your own property: identify each item, state what it is worth, and give her a deadline to return it or pay for it. 5. If she does not, file a claim for the value of your items in the small claims department of the magistrate division in the county where she lives. Bring your photos, your October and March messages, and any proof of what the items cost or were worth. 6. Do not sell, discard or damage her belongings, and do not condition their return on payment of the storage rent you have been paying. Both of those turn your strong position into a weak one.
*Attorney review is supported by AI-assisted drafting and legal research algorithms. Use of this Chat does not create an attorney-client relationship.
By using this service you agree to our Terms of Use and our Privacy Policy.
Courts & Legal Aid in Idaho
- File or look up a case through the Idaho Courts.
- Get free civil legal help from Idaho Legal Aid Services.
- Use the LSC — Find Legal Aid to find a local legal-aid office by ZIP code.
- Use the LawHelp.org to browse free legal information and self-help resources.
- Use the ABA Lawyer Referral Directory to get matched with a local attorney through your state bar.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I charge her for the storage rent I have paid for the last year?
You can ask for it, but you cannot hold her property hostage until she pays. If you want reimbursement, make it a claim: demand it in writing, and if she refuses, include it in a small claims filing along with your damaged-property claim. A judge is far more likely to consider storage costs sympathetically if you have already released her belongings.
What if she refuses to pick up her things at all?
Document every offer you make and every refusal, in writing. Continued refusal after a genuine, unconditional offer to return the property is your defense to any later claim that you wrongfully kept it. Do not simply throw the items out — give her repeated written notice and keep proof of it.
How do I prove what my truck clip and car roof were worth if they are gone?
Photographs, purchase receipts, listings for comparable parts, and a written estimate or statement from a shop or salvage yard all help. Also save her March 2025 message saying the items are no longer on her property — an admission that they are gone is often the hardest part of the case to prove.
